Roofing Code Upgrades on Insurance Claims: What Contractors Should Know

By Steven Dye, roofing contractor and founder of RecountRoof · Updated October 20, 2026 · 6 min read

When a roof is replaced, the new roof generally has to meet the code in force today, not the code the house was built under. That gap is why code items are among the most common, and most defensible, roofing supplement items.

Which code applies

Most of the U.S. builds houses under some edition of the International Residential Code (IRC), adopted by the state, the county or the city, often with local amendments. Some states set one code statewide; others leave it to each city and county. Start with the roofing code status for your state, then confirm the edition with the local building department.

Code items that show up on reroofs

  • Drip edge at eaves and rakes (2012 IRC and later, R905.2.8.5).
  • Ice barrier at eaves in areas with a history of ice damming, as designated by the jurisdiction (R905.1.2 in recent editions).
  • Underlayment type and application per the code and manufacturer (R905.1.1 in the 2018 and later editions).
  • Tear-off down to the deck when replacing, and limits on recovering over existing layers (R908 in recent editions).
  • Replacement of flashing, vent collars and metal edging that are rusted, damaged or deteriorated, rather than reinstalling them (R908.5 in recent editions).
  • Attic ventilation ratios (R806).
  • Installation per the manufacturer’s instructions (R905.1), which brings starter, hip and ridge and fastening requirements into the code.

Section numbers move between IRC editions. Always cite the section from the edition your jurisdiction adopted.

Ordinance or law coverage

Many homeowner policies exclude the extra cost of meeting current code unless the policy includes ordinance or law coverage, which is often an endorsement limited to a percentage of the dwelling limit. Some states require carriers to offer it. Whether and how much a policy pays is a coverage question between the homeowner and the carrier.

For the contractor, the job is simpler: document that the item is required by the adopted code, with the section, edition and quantity, so the homeowner and the adjuster have what they need to apply the policy.

How to present code items in a supplement

  1. Name the jurisdiction and the adopted code edition.
  2. Quote the section in one line.
  3. Give the quantity from the measurement report.
  4. Attach the code page or a link to the jurisdiction’s adoption ordinance.

RecountRoof looks up the code your city or county adopted anywhere in the U.S., then flags code items missing from the estimate with the section attached. See how it works.

This guide is general information for contractors, not legal or insurance advice. Code requirements vary by jurisdiction and edition; confirm with your local building department.

Related guides