How to Write a Roofing Supplement the Adjuster Will Approve
By Steven Dye, roofing contractor and founder of RecountRoof · Updated October 20, 2026 · 7 min read
A roofing supplement is a request to the insurance carrier to add or correct items on the adjuster’s estimate so it matches what it actually costs to replace the roof correctly. Most first estimates are written fast, from a short inspection, and they routinely miss quantities, accessories and code items.
The supplements that get paid are not the longest ones. They are the ones where every line item is tied to something the adjuster can verify in a minute: a measurement, a manufacturer instruction, a code section or a photo.
1. Get the right documents together first
Before you write anything, collect the pieces the supplement will lean on:
- The adjuster’s estimate (usually an Xactimate PDF) and the claim number.
- A third-party measurement report: EagleView, Hover, GAF QuickMeasure, Roofr or similar.
- The installation instructions for the exact shingle line you are installing.
- The residential code your city or county has adopted, and any local amendments. See roofing code requirements by state.
- Dated job photos: overall elevations, each slope, damage, eaves, rakes, valleys, penetrations, flashing and decking.
2. Compare the estimate to the measurements, line by line
Start with quantities, because they are the easiest items to prove. Put the estimate next to the measurement report and check each of these:
- Total roof area in squares, and the waste percentage applied. See how waste factor works on insurance estimates.
- Eaves and rakes (linear feet), which drive drip edge and starter.
- Hips and ridges (linear feet), which drive ridge cap.
- Valleys (linear feet), which drive valley underlayment or metal.
- Pitch of each slope, which drives steep charges, and number of stories, which drives high-roof charges.
When the adjuster used a different number, write both numbers in the supplement and name the source of yours. “Ridge cap: estimate 64 LF, EagleView report 112 LF” is hard to argue with.
3. Add what is missing, with a reason for each item
Next, list items that are not on the estimate at all. The usual suspects are starter, drip edge, ice and water barrier, step and counter flashing, pipe jacks, ventilation, permits and steep or high-roof charges. We keep a full roofing supplement checklist.
Give every added item one reason, in one of three forms:
- Code: cite the section and edition, for example “2021 IRC R905.2.8.5, drip edge required at eaves and rakes”.
- Manufacturer: quote the installation instruction, for example the shingle maker’s starter or hip-and-ridge requirement.
- Field condition: a photo or measurement showing the item exists and has to be replaced.
Under most adopted editions of the IRC, roof coverings must be installed per the manufacturer’s instructions (R905.1). That is what turns a manufacturer requirement into a code requirement.
4. Write it so the adjuster can approve it quickly
Adjusters handle a lot of files. Make yours easy to say yes to:
- Open with the claim number, property address, homeowner name and date of loss.
- One short sentence on why you are writing: the estimate does not cover a code-compliant replacement.
- A numbered list of items. For each: the line item, the quantity, the quantity on the original estimate, and the reason.
- Attach the measurement report, manufacturer pages, code excerpts and photos, labeled to match the item numbers.
- Close by asking for a revised estimate or a reinspection by a specific date.
Keep it factual. Stick to scope, quantities and code. Coverage decisions are between the homeowner and the carrier, and many states restrict contractors from negotiating a claim on a homeowner’s behalf.
5. Follow up and track the answer
Log when you sent it and who received it. If you get a partial approval or a denial, answer each point separately instead of resending the whole package. See how to respond when the adjuster denies a supplement.
Doing this faster
Steps 2 and 3 are where the hours go. RecountRoof reads the adjuster estimate and your measurement report, checks each roofing line item against the measurements, the shingle manufacturer and your local code, and drafts the supplement with quantities and sources for you to review. See how it works, or try your first claim free.
This guide is general information for contractors, not legal or insurance advice. Code requirements vary by jurisdiction and edition; confirm with your local building department.