Roofing Supplement Checklist: 15 Items Adjusters Commonly Miss
By Steven Dye, roofing contractor and founder of RecountRoof · Updated October 20, 2026 · 6 min read
Run every adjuster estimate against this list before you sign a contract or order material. Each item below shows up missing or short on real roofing estimates, and each one can be supported with a measurement, a manufacturer instruction, a code section or a photo.
Quantities
- Waste factor too low for the roof shape. Hip roofs and cut-up roofs waste far more than a simple gable. More on waste.
- Roof area short of the measurement report, often from a missed slope, dormer or detached garage.
- Ridge cap linear feet short, or ridge cap missing entirely when only field shingles were priced.
- Starter course missing or priced only at the eaves when the manufacturer calls for it at rakes too.
Edge metal and underlayment
- Drip edge at eaves and rakes, required at shingle roofs since the 2012 IRC (R905.2.8.5). Drip edge and ice barrier code.
- Ice and water barrier at the eaves where the local code requires it, typically to 24 inches inside the exterior wall line.
- Ice and water or valley underlayment in valleys.
- Synthetic or felt underlayment priced at the right coverage, including laps.
Flashing and penetrations
- Step flashing at sidewalls, and counter flashing where it has to be removed to get the step flashing out.
- Chimney flashing, and a cricket where a chimney is more than 30 inches wide measured perpendicular to the slope (IRC R903.2.2).
- Pipe jacks, and other vent flashing that is rusted, damaged or deteriorated (reroofing provisions in recent IRC editions don’t allow it to be reinstalled).
- Ventilation: replacement of damaged box vents, ridge vent, turbines or exhaust caps, and enough net free area to meet the code ratio.
Labor and job charges
- Steep charges on slopes of 7/12 and steeper, broken out by pitch range.
- High-roof charges for two-story and taller roof areas.
- Additional layers to tear off, when there is more than one layer of shingles.
- Permit and inspection fees where the city requires a roofing permit.
- Overhead and profit when a general contractor is reasonably needed to coordinate the job. More on O&P.
How to use the list
Don’t send all fifteen. Send the ones you can prove for this roof, each with its quantity and its reason. A short supplement where every line is supported gets approved faster than a long one with guesses in it. See how to write a roofing supplement.
RecountRoof runs this check automatically against the adjuster estimate, your measurement report and the code your city adopted, and shows the math and source for each item. Try it on a claim.
This guide is general information for contractors, not legal or insurance advice. Code requirements vary by jurisdiction and edition; confirm with your local building department.