Roofing Supplement Software vs. Hiring a Supplement Company
By Steven Dye, roofing contractor and founder of RecountRoof · Updated October 20, 2026 · 4 min read
Roofing contractors have three ways to get supplements done: write them in-house by hand, hire a supplement company, or use supplement software and keep it in-house. Each one makes sense for some shops.
Writing supplements by hand
Free, and you control every word, but it is slow. Comparing an estimate line by line to a measurement report, the manufacturer instructions and the local code takes hours per claim, and things get missed when the office is busy.
Hiring a supplement company
A good supplement company brings experience and frees up your time. The trade-offs: many charge a percentage of the increase they win, so your cost grows with the size of the claim; you wait on their turnaround; and someone outside your company is writing to the carrier about your job.
Using supplement software
Software does the line-by-line check in minutes and drafts the supplement, and you review and send it yourself. The cost is fixed per claim no matter how big the supplement is, and the claim file stays with you.
RecountRoof was built by a Denver roofing contractor for exactly this. It checks the adjuster estimate against your EagleView, Hover, GAF QuickMeasure or Roofr report, the shingle manufacturer and your local code, then drafts the supplement, the adjuster reply and the material order. Your first claim is free, then $39 per claim or less with a prepaid pack. See pricing.
Which one fits
- A few claims a year and plenty of time: by hand can work. Use the supplement checklist.
- High volume and no one in the office who knows supplements: a supplement company or software plus a trained office person.
- You want to keep control and keep the cost fixed: software.
This guide is general information for contractors, not legal or insurance advice. Code requirements vary by jurisdiction and edition; confirm with your local building department.